Friday, June 27, 2025

CD vs Vinyl Debate

Generated on request by Bing image Creator.
In order to reproduce sound faithfully, the Nyquist-Shannon sampling theorem says that a sound can be perfectly reconstructed from its samples if the sampling rate is at least twice the highest frequency component of the signal. That's not the fundamental frequency of the sound, it's the highest frequency component of the signal when its spectrum is viewed in the frequency domain. The timbre or difference in tone colour between a pure tone and e.g. the sound from an organ, both with the same pitch and loudness, is that the organ sound has a fundamental frequency and higher harmonics (multiples of the fundamental frequency). The combination of, and amplitude of harmonics is one factor that makes the timbre of a musical note from a piano different from that of e.g. a flute or violin. The discussion in the forum at the link suggests that CD recordings should be better than analogue recordings on vinyl, considering that sampling is done at 44 kHz (twice the 22 kHz bandwidth allowed for audio signals). However there are other factors involved, and another forum member suggests that compression of the signal is involved when the pressing master is made from the original master, and production CDs suffer in sound quality due to this. Compression is necessary to reduce dynamic range (the difference between the loudness of loud and soft sounds) so that recordings can be listened to on earbuds rather than a hi-fi system, the latter having greater dynamic range capacity. This compression of dynamic range is distinct from the compression of the size of files to reduce the storage space required on media. That compression is variable and produces either lower quality/smaller file size or higher quality/larger file size recordings, typically in the MP3 (for audio) or MPEG (for video) file format. This is similar to the way bitmapped images are compressed into a JPEG image file. Unlike MP£ files, sound tracks on a normal CD aren't compressed and the data is in a raw format that can be read by the electronics.

A debate on the subject here