Monday, August 04, 2025

Attacking the Brasses With Acid

Shiny fittings on the newly-painted front door, the result of hours of polishing. © Eugene Brennan
Painting is something I tend to procrastinate on and life is too short for cleaning brasses regularly. I do a good job of cleaning the hardware on the front door every two or three years when I paint it, but then I only polish the brasses a couple of times before I lose interest and have more pressing chores to attend to. After three years of non-cleaning, a thick layer of oxide builds up on the fittings which takes several hours to remove with wire wool and Brasso. (Brass is an alloy of copper and zinc, so the tarnish is zinc oxide and copper oxide). There may be other compounds making up tarnish such as acetates (The green patina on domes of public buildings and the Statue of Liberty, known as verdigris, is copper acetate. This forms naturally or is created artificially by using acetic acid on the copper sheeting, pre-construction). Anyway to cut a long story short, from my school chemistry I knew that acid dissolves oxides and turns them into salts. Someone gave me half a 5 litre container of Ecokem phosphoric acid they didn't want. Phosphoric is used for cleaning rust (iron oxide) off iron and steel and descaling lime build-up from sanitary fittings. So I tried the stuff and it did a reasonable job of quickly removing the tarnish. 

Phosphoric acid, a product used for descaling. © Eugene Brennan

This is a faster method than using wire wool or Brasso, but I'll use the latter to further clean and polish the brass (Brasso contains a mild abrasive). I noticed the brass had turned pink and suspected that the acid had reacted to a greater extent on the zinc in the brass alloy, dissolving it and leaving the copper behind. My suspicion was confirmed by Grok. After washing the acid off, the brass turned black and brown when it dried. Not sure what produced that chemical reaction. Will have to ask Grok for a follow up.

The acid dezincified the brass, leaving copper behind. © Eugene Brennan

Edit: Grok said it's copper oxide, formed by the rapid oxidation of porous copper after dezincification by oxygen in the air or rinse water. It transpired that the dezincification was superficial and I used Brasso to finish the job, leaving the fittings perfectly shiny.

Grok confirmed the dezincification. © Eugene Brennan